Carpet4 wrote:Edit: Oh wow... actually the clipping only happened on VLC because I forgot the sound there at 125%, so it only really happens on the ubuntu default video player.
Yes, I expected something like that. Exporting at -1dB should not be a problem, and you should not concern yourself with whether some listeners may use a player (or monitoring system) that mangles the playback. That's their problem. I can't comment on the suitability of ubuntu's default player, but just FYI, there's been some noise on the Interwebz lately about VLC delivering malware. You might want to look into it.
More important is whether the audio exceeds the loudness standards of the various streaming services, but a solo piano piece that hasn't been massively compressed is unlikely to exceed any of those standards no matter how high it's peaking.
Out of curiosity, I did a quick test exporting audio from the Standalone Pianoteq, and comparing it to audio rendered by the VSTi in Cakewalk, and the two were very close - enough to null significantly when one was phase-inverted. Interestingly, I found that Pianoteq does not play back exactly the same way twice, probably due to deliberately random elements in the modelling that are intended to help it feel more alive (or possibly unavoidable...?), so the renders from two different hosts are never going to be identical even with all other settings being equal. Incidentally I disabled the reverb and delay FX for testing, and the level was low enough that the limiter should not have been engaging.
P.S. Given the nearly non-existent metering in the Standalone Pianoteq, I would highly recommend running the VSTi in a DAW to get a better grip on levels and loudness for distribution purposes.
Last edited by brundlefly (19-04-2022 07:38)