Topic: Two simultaneous MIDI recorders ?

Bonjour,

I can run two instances of Pianoteq standalone with two different presets and controlled by two keyboards.
But there is only one MIDI recorder for both instances.
Is there a way to have one recorder for each instance (and running simultaneously)?

Merci !

Re: Two simultaneous MIDI recorders ?

Gaston wrote:

I can run two instances of Pianoteq standalone with two different presets and controlled by two keyboards.
But there is only one MIDI recorder for both instances.
Is there a way to have one recorder for each instance (and running simultaneously)?

How about running the two instances as plug-ins (VST) in a Host such as Cantabile?  Each instance on a difference MIDI channel.  Then have Cantabile save the Input as a MIDI Recording, and you should have both instances present, each on its own channel.

Re: Two simultaneous MIDI recorders ?

The idea of unsing 2 VST is indeed a solution, but why not a DAW instead of Cantabile?
There are plenty of them, including free ones, like GarageBand if you are on a Mac or Cakewalk (BandLab) if you are on Windows.
Just create 2 tracks, insert 2 instances, assign a different MIDI channel and press Record.

Re: Two simultaneous MIDI recorders ?

Thank you both for your suggestions.
Cantabile: I have already practiced, for quite a long time.
This was the solution I had found to replace the retrospective recording of Cubase when I switched to Reaper.
But it is much more cumbersome to manage than the MIDI recorder embedded in Pianoteq.
Two tracks in the Daw, of course. This is what I do in the lack of a pure Pianoteq solution.
Anyway my playing in Pianoteq always end up in Reaper.
But with Pianoteq, when I stop playing it stops recording without me having to tell him.
If I hit Record in Reaper, either I decide to let it run, but it can last half an hour and I end up with a huge MIDI file, or I have to stop it manually, Reaper doesn't know when I have finished a phrase.

Last edited by Gaston (18-11-2018 12:44)

Re: Two simultaneous MIDI recorders ?

Yes, I can see what Gaston is getting at. The auto-record in Pianoteq is a great benefit, however, it does come at a cost. At present, the preset settings are not embedded in the midi file when you use Pianoteq, and settings that may have sounded good for a particular session could be lost. In Reaper, you get all the settings recalled, but not the auto-record. It's catch-22!