Topic: Headphone comparison
I went shopping for headphones today since I recently decided to switch from my closed-back Sony MDR-7506's to an open back design. Figured I'd post my findings for whoever is interested. Many many thanks to those of you who offerred advice in my other thread. It was great info to have heading into this decision.
I tried:
New Sony MDR-7506 $85
Grado SR-80i $100
Koss Porta Pro $50
AKG K240 $70
Beyerdynamic DT990 Pro $150
The new Sony's sounded the same but were way more comfy than my current ones because my ear pads are a mess. Had NOT realized how important that is, and will be replacing them immediately.
The Grados (which I ultimately bought) sounded almost the same to my ears, though the store was noisy. When I got them home, I can hear that their sound is just a little darker, more bass-y than the Sony's. They are comfortable on my head and light! The ear pads are a little scratchy, but I suppose that will get better. If not, they do have other ear pads you can get.
The Koss, AKG, and Beyerdynamic were all MORE bass heavy than the Grado's. The Beyerdynamic were the softest in volume, but of all the ones I tried they were by FAR the most comfortable. Oh, they were so comfy. However, I liked the Grado's sound better, and I couldn't see spending $50 more just for the comfort if the sound wasn't also superior. The AKG were supremely UNcomfortable for my head and ears. I couldn't imagine getting used to them. The Porta Pros sounded good, bass heavy like I said, but they seemed too flimsy for my taste. I didn't love the form factor.
I'm really glad I got to try them all back to back. It was very interesting.
So, I'm happy. I'm going to get new ear pads for my Sony's and keep the Grado's too. I think it's the best of both worlds. I have two good, comfy, linear headsets, one closed, one open.
Also, I am VERY happy that I could tell the differences in the sound, even in the noisy store, and that my impressions were confirmed by frequency response graphs on headphone.com. I hear better and more critically than I thought!
Oh and a footnote: as soon as I saw them and tried them on, I realized that Grado's are the headphones used at the Yale music library. I spent many MANY hours listening to all kinds of great recordings there with them. So there's even some nostalgia associated with them for me.
Listening to Mitsuko Uchida play some Beethoven with them right now. I'm very happy. The open back design really does make a difference. It's much more like listening live!