Topic: My records bad metallic sound quality

hello, I get bad sound quality in Pianoteq Stage records.

Piano: Casio Celviano AP-460
Sound Card: Focusrite Scarlett Solo MK2 sound card
System: İntel core i5 4200m - 8gb ram - Windows 10 - Cubase Elements 9 (hp probook 450 g1 e9y39ea)

can you help me please. i am share sample record: https://youtu.be/wVV5lXAHNto

can you review the mid file. why there is such a disorder. no problems with mid-files downloaded from internet. sound quality is bad in my records.

https://www.mediafire.com/file/u48cbb8c822yudy/test.mid

thanks in advance.

Re: My records bad metallic sound quality

cmusicpr2 wrote:

hello, I get bad sound quality in Pianoteq Stage records.


can you help me please. i am share sample record: https://youtu.be/wVV5lXAHNto

can you review the mid file. why there is such a disorder. no problems with mid-files downloaded from internet. sound quality is bad in my records.

https://www.mediafire.com/file/u48cbb8c822yudy/test.mid

thanks in advance.


Hell Mr. Cmusicpr2:

I downloaded your midi file and launched it into Digital Performer 9 DAW using Pianoteq's Steinway D Prelude stock preset.  Here is what I found:

The midi file you attempted to create had been step-entered and then modified to look as though it was played live.  Such was not the case:  Why?  The right hand melody was wayyyy too loud with respect to the left hand, and there were several instances where you forgot to change the note-on velocities, as they were all the same in certain areas.

In addition, it looks to me as though you tried to fool your audience into thinking it was played live (when in fact it was step entered) by attempting to change the durations of whole sections such that they did not look quantized.

I went ahead and modified the midi file you submitted; but rather than publishing your work for you here, I suggest that you modify all of the note velocities by 50%.  In this manner, the right hand will not sound nearly as loud and out of place with respect to the left hand.  In addition, I can see where you precisely entered the sustain pedal (Midi Controller #64) at rather precise on (127) and off (0) locations.

So I suggest you take this midi file, highlight all of the note-on velocities and change them to 30% to 50% of their edited values, and the piano will sound much nicer.

In addition, where ever the theme repeats, you may wish to step enter some Midi Controller #67 (soft pedal) which will help give the impression of some musicianship.

Sorry, ahead of time, for sounding harsh, but I can smell a midi-rat from miles away, especially when one tries to modify the performance, and then complain that Pianoteq sounds metallic with it.

Cheers,

Joe

Re: My records bad metallic sound quality

unfortunately I can't solve the problem. I received a direct mid recording from the piano. can you please review: https://www.mediafire.com/file/7vx5pc6i...ECSONG.MID  Could you arrange this for me? I download and review.

is a problem because of the piano? sound sounds bad and treble. Sound resonates and degradation continues


velocity reduced sound(my record)
https://youtu.be/jOt6Jk6La8o

mid file downloaded from internet
https://youtu.be/u_yF0qAXNG8

Last edited by cmusicpr2 (12-05-2019 06:02)