Topic: Kaway ES7 and MP6 partial sustain support

Hi,
     I am going to buy a Kaway DP (ES7 or MP6).

I know both models supports continuous sustain, but I don't know if the CC message (suppose cc64) are sent via midi out or if only on-off signals are sent.

Does someone tried it with Pianoteq?

Tnx in advance, sorry for my english.

Massimo

Re: Kaway ES7 and MP6 partial sustain support

ES7 sends what Kawai terms 'half-pedal', and by that, means sends at least some variety of MIDI values. I've never read any and Kawai may keep them secret, but in practice it means ES7's Sustain acts like a mechanical piano's - varied amounts of damping can be applied, from slight to full.

Last edited by custral (25-05-2013 16:32)

Re: Kaway ES7 and MP6 partial sustain support

custral wrote:

ES7 sends what Kawai terms 'half-pedal', and by that, means sends at least some variety of MIDI values. I've never read any and Kawai may keep them secret, but in practice it means ES7's Sustain acts like a mechanical piano's - varied amounts of damping can be applied, from slight to full.

Nice to know: the manual of the ES7 is not clear about this point; the absence of partial pedaling is one of the reason to buy another DP.

So, it should be possible to control partial pedaling on Pianoteq: if values are sent on different cc, they can be remapped on Panoteq easily.

Next week, I'll go on the shop and will try the ES7.

Thank you again for the response.

Massimo

Re: Kaway ES7 and MP6 partial sustain support

Hello chaps,

Just to clarify this point, the ES7 does indeed send a range of values when depressing the pedal.

It's true that the discreet values that are sent are not written in the owner's manual, however this may change in the future.

I believe Kawai first introduced half-pedalling (i.e. sending progressive damper pedal values) support on portable digital pianos several years ago, and this has been a standard feature since the MP5...if not before.

Kind regards,
James
x

Last edited by Cute James (28-05-2013 05:58)
My mind says Kawai, but my heart says Nord.

Re: Kaway ES7 and MP6 partial sustain support

Cute James wrote:

Hello chaps,

Just to clarify this point, the ES7 does indeed send a range of values when depressing the pedal.

Thank you for the info James! Any suggestion about wich model to buy?
Non-piano sounds doesn't matter, i'm looking only for a piano with nice acoustic piano sound and action for studiyng.

Thank you

m.

Re: Kaway ES7 and MP6 partial sustain support

barmassimo,

Any suggestion about wich model to buy?
Non-piano sounds doesn't matter, i'm looking only for a piano with nice acoustic piano sound and action for studiyng.

Given the choice between the two, the ES7 is perhaps more suitable as a practise/learning instrument.  Moveover, it features a superior three-sensor keyboard action and higher resolution tone generator compared to the MP6.

Kind regards,
James
x

Last edited by Cute James (30-05-2013 01:17)
My mind says Kawai, but my heart says Nord.

Re: Kaway ES7 and MP6 partial sustain support

Cute James wrote:

barmassimo,
Given the choice between the two, the ES7 is perhaps more suitable as a practise/learning instrument.  Moveover, it features a superior keyboard action and tone generator compared to the MP6.
x

I agree. Today I went in the shop and tried the ES7: I could not stop playing, so I bring it home :-)

It works very well with pianoteq, the action seems perfect without hacking the velocity curve. The pedal sends continuous values (more or less) on cc64 as expected, so it works with PT with the default settings.

I don't know if I prefere the internal piano or PT, I need some more test.

A note about the action: don't know why, but some quick passages are harder with the ES7 than with my previous digital piano (Yamaha P80). Probably the new keyboard is more "pianistic" and needs to be played differently.

In the end I'm very satisfied, I tried the M10 time ago: nice machine, but with a difference of 1000€ and 10kg I think that for studying the ES7 is a more reasonable choiche.

Thanks to all for the support, if somebody has some question about the ES7 and PT i'll be happy to answer.

Bye,

massimo

Re: Kaway ES7 and MP6 partial sustain support

barmassimo wrote:

It works very well with pianoteq, the action seems perfect without hacking the velocity curve. ...... .

I don't know if I prefere the internal piano or PT, I need some more test.

A note about the action: don't know why, but some quick passages are harder with the ES7 than with my previous digital piano (Yamaha P80). Probably the new keyboard is more "pianistic" and needs to be played differently.

You could try one of the two alternate Pianoteq keyboard velocity curves (Slow, Moderately Slow) and see if they make an impression-difference (important to playing, adds up to "heard/felt differently", a psycholgical trick/adjustment analogous to astronauts learning to move around on the moon).

You'd lose no (giant) capability-equality between the onboard (Kawai) piano sounds and the offboard (Pianoteq) ones, because ES7 has equivalent curves of its own, if you want to keep these two excellent sound-sources both in play - (while ES7 additionally has two learning modes, that with identical material used might produce results approximate to what Pianoteq can learn of your touch .... and in any case you can set-to, and design, a Pianoteq match to whatever ES7 has ended up with).

When my Kawai VPC1 finally arrives I fully intend to park ES7 behind it, pass MIDI thru, and keep the ES7 sounds available and ready. They're that good.

Last edited by custral (30-05-2013 07:58)

Re: Kaway ES7 and MP6 partial sustain support

custral wrote:

You could try one of the two alternate Pianoteq keyboard velocity curves (Slow, Moderately Slow)

Thank you custral, maybe I need to be more clear (sorry for my english):

by "harder" I meant simply "difficult to play": I have problems when I try to trigger the same note twice very quickly (in italian the word is "ribattuto", don't know in english).
I frequently loose se second note. Maybe this is related to the let-off simulation, don't know.

Anywai, I'll do some experiment with velocity curves also.

Bye

massimo

Re: Kaway ES7 and MP6 partial sustain support

I understood what you mean just as you mean it, and having the same keyboard proposed a trick (which by the way I've yet to try myself) which might help. You have to wonder, why name those curves that way? The touch doesn't itself alter, the ratio of output per unit force does is all you can say. Much as the the same kick as on earth would jump the astronaut out of the football grass and into the stands, on the moon; and reversely. You modify your kick by the results generated, and that's the trick built into the curve.

Anyway, without changing curves as I passed the ES7 this afternoon, I experimented with shaking the hand/arm while holding the striking finger rigid (shaking the finger doesn't work, yet at anyrate) in order to get fast repetition of a note. It may be THE way, in that depth of shake is easily kept constant, (and after that, you'd teach yourself different depths and different striking extents along the key to manage volume, which of course I didn't do in passing this afternoon).

Repetition must always have been troublesome, or why did the classicals write so many trills but so few one-note equivalents, like almost none?

Then they had to shoehorn in a specialised mechanical trick to help this (called Repetition natch); but help is all, it no way is a complete fix.

Evgeny Kissin is as accomplished a pianist as you can look up, and I posted a clip of a Polonaise of his in one of the recent VPC1 threads. It occasionally uses part of a rhythmic figure that's a constant part of the bass accompaniment in the Grand Polonaise Brillante which follows Chopin's Andante Spianato.

Accompaniment goes Dah, Dada Dit Dah Dit Dah; Dah, Dada Dit Dah Dit Dah etc, and the second da in Dada follows quick, or else, and quieter than the first Da, or else. Anything else is wrong. Well, Dah, Dada Dit turns up occasionally in Kissin's Polonaise too, and is sometimes right and sometimes daDa.

Which London to a brick isn't what Chopin wanted - or Kissin. And that's on a Steinway.

We can't do without Dah, Dada Dit and similar, and it can beat the best playing the best - (including the best mechanical Repetition ever). So aim to get along with means you can directly control - shake, finger-change, change strike-point, part-pedal fudge, anything that helps. So I say to myself. Forget that Kawai or Steinway will solve it.

Last edited by custral (30-05-2013 13:38)

Re: Kaway ES7 and MP6 partial sustain support

custral wrote:

I understood what you mean just as you mean it, and having the same keyboard proposed a trick (which by the way I've yet to try myself) which might help.

You are absolutely right: I tried the mentioned curves in PT and I can hear the "missing" notes; the same happens if I choose the light+ velocity curve and use the ES7 internal sounds.

Apparently, when playing with normal curve, the "missing" note is still emitted, but at very low volume.

Interesting, thanks for the tip, now I'm sure that it is not a keyboard issue, but only a limit of my own technique (not a news, I began studying few months ago).

Now that my keyboard underline my limits I'm sure I'll improve on the next months. :-)

Bye

massimo