Topic: Working with a sequencer and moving parts?

Can I ask people to discuss how they move parts (as in verse and chorus, A and B sections) around using their sequencer? I'm thinking in terms of a single instrument, here--a piano in other words.

Using a basic version of Cubase, I've started recording a piece and then chopping it up in the Tracks view, moving each section to a different track. This lets me easily move things around. If I want to repeat the verse again before reaching the chorus, it's simple to drag the chorus over to the right and the verse over to the left. It occurs to me that I could simply record the entire thing to two tracks simultaneously and then select and delete the unwanted sections from each track to reach the same editing situation. Obviously, I could just record the parts to separate tracks, but I dislike the interruption this creates. (All of the methods seem preferable to keeping everything on one track and having to find the section I want and then worrying about overwriting notes.)

Is this the most efficient way to work? I understand that if there were multiple instruments, this method would become more complex and confusing. But for now I'm thinking in simple, one instrument terms. Or are there other sequencers (with a score editor) that would, in some way I can't imagine, make the process still more simple?

Last edited by Jake Johnson (21-11-2012 15:29)

Re: Working with a sequencer and moving parts?

Hello Jake,

I have worked with sequencing of multiple "instruments" in Digital Performer (exclusively Mac platform until only very recently formatted for PC in version 8), and might be able to help you simplify your process.  Everything I write here should be entirely compatible with your version of Cubase.

In the case of writing for piano, with various verses and choruses, I would suggest first that you simply record your piece on a given "master" stereo track without any extra verses and choruses, and keep your master track intact without chopping it into pieces.  For convenience, you may wish to add markers to your master track, such as Intro, Verse, Chorus, Variations, Ending.  Each of these markers will represent the material from which you select for copying (not dragging only) into your eventual "working" track.

Next, create a second stereo track that is empty at the outset, with a separate instantiation of Pianoteq.  This will be the starting point of your "working" track, mentioned above in the previous paragraph.
 
Now, here is where I differ from your method as described in your original post:

Rather than chopping your master track into pieces that may possibly get lost or corrupted, simply "highlight" your intro in the tracks menu, and then COPY (not drag -- and lose your original intact version) that intro into your working track.  Then proceed with COPYING the other parts in as many repetitions as you require from the master track into your working track.

When you are satisfied with your work, it is only a matter of switching off Pianoteq from your original master file.

The reason I suggest using a separate instantiation of Pianoteq is so that you will not confound Pianoteq with duplicate midi note on/off commands if you happen to play both tracks at the same time.  Otherwise, you may encounter dropped notes or other midi anomalies that occur due to playing one instantiation of Pianoteq through two simultaneous tracks.

* * * * * * *

The beauty of the method I described is that you are able to leave your original performance intact.  If you need to return to a given piece at some time in the future, you will have retained a copy of your original performance; it will be much easier for you to reconstruct your ideas, than if you had a fragmented master copy after having dragged bits and pieces of a chopped original performance.

Hope this helps,

Cheers,

Joe

Last edited by jcfelice88keys (26-11-2012 19:30)

Re: Working with a sequencer and moving parts?

Thank you for this suggestion -

jfelice88keys wrote:

The reason I suggest using a separate instantiation of Pianoteq is so that you will not confound Pianoteq with duplicate midi note on/off commands if you happen to play both tracks at the same time.  Otherwise, you may encounter dropped notes or other midi anomalies that occur due to playing one instantiation of Pianoteq through two simultaneous tracks.

- it may clarify inconstant behaviour in NOTION, when using multiple voices; suggests a workpast as well.

The other methods are sensible too.

ADDED; plus after your saying Digital Performer's now for PC, I'm for IT. At least I'll go look. Helpful itself.

Last edited by custral (27-11-2012 15:19)

Re: Working with a sequencer and moving parts?

Thank-you both for responding. After seeing that over a hundred people had viewed my question without responding, I had come to think that I was fumbling around with something so simple and well-known that it needed no response. (Which may still be the case.)

I now have Notion, but do not at present have the time needed to explore it fully. I'll post more about using it with Pianoteq when I can. In the meantime, I hope that you, custral, can find the time to share your experiences with us in the thread about Notion.

By accident, I ran across another, older sequencer, Metro, by a company named Sagan, that can divide a track into sections easily. I like it, but it has an older-looking interface, is not well-known, and is somewhat expensive. It may not be wonderful from a notation perspective, but it does have a score view and it seems to be good in many ways in terms of defining and manipulating sections, judging from the demo I downloaded:

http://www.sagantech.biz/   

Anyone here familiar with this program? Impressions?

I ran across it when reading a thread on KVR about lesser-known sequencers:

http://www.kvraudio.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=365877

Many of the posts in the thread link to sequencers without a score view. But some may be of interest in terms of editing-ease. And I wish I had the time to explore editing in the well-known sequencers, as well. There are at least ten, now?

Last edited by Jake Johnson (27-11-2012 19:13)

Re: Working with a sequencer and moving parts?

And Joe,

Thanks for the suggestion about creating a second track and copying. This makes sense for working in the score view, as well. You've probably saved me several hours of work.

Re: Working with a sequencer and moving parts?

Jake Johnson wrote:

And Joe,

Thanks for the suggestion about creating a second track and copying. This makes sense for working in the score view, as well. You've probably saved me several hours of work.


Hello Jake,

My pleasure to help you or anyone else in this forum with the double track idea, using two instantiations of Pianoteq.  Many happy hours doing things other than chopping up only one track.

Sincerely,

Joe

Re: Working with a sequencer and moving parts?

Thanks again, Joe.

There is currently a discussion on KVR about the sequencer that I mentioned, Metro, which seems to be designed for isolating and moving sections\passages:

http://www.kvraudio.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=362244

I do not own it and I am not a beta tester for it, so I cannot vouch for it. But it looks interesting and is on sale and has a free demo download. I wish I had more time to experiment right now. (I'm hoping, I suppose, that someone else will review its capabilities and work-flow. )

Last edited by Jake Johnson (27-12-2012 23:18)