Topic: playing live with an ochestra

I know this has been already discussed before but I would have your opinions please: I've been asked to play in september together with a string orchestra (+/- 25 musicians). I'd like to  give both the audience AND the musicians a musical AND visual experience as close as possible to a real piano. My question is: where to put the speakers? I've many of them, so that's not an issue, and I'm using a Tascam US2000 as audio interface, so I've 4 independent out's. Usually, I send a stereo mix to the FOH, and another for me, in a "studio" config, i.e., the speakers facing me. But here, that would leave to de desired for the other musicians, and then there is the visual impact... I don't want to "show" the speakers too much, but placing them on the floor would ruin the treble very soon...
Any ideas? Suggestions?

Re: playing live with an ochestra

Not sure if I can be of much help to your question, but I have to say that it's very nice to know that pianoteq will be played together with a orchestra.

Remamber to get a friend with a cancorder and record the whole thing .   

Abou the speakers direction, I sugest to you make a test with the orchestra, during rehearsal, with also someone in the audience to check if the sound reach well there.

Give priority to the audience.

Re: playing live with an ochestra

I'll supply the camcorder as well, but the problem is the man behind it ! Last time I played with this orchestra (with an Alesis Fusion synth, not yet PTQ), the guy managed to switch the auto focus out and all the video was plain bad :-(

The sound for the audience is not too much of a problem: a pair of speakers each side of the orchestra will do the job. It's more the "monitoring" side (for me and the musicians) that is a concern for me. A "wedge" or two will probably only reach the first rank of the musicians, leaving the second violins and the alti out of reach. I'm thinking about putting another pair of speakers beyond the FOH, but oriented toward the musicians. But then, those speakers will be relatively far from my own playing position... and the "global" experience will probably be far away from what a real piano would do. I was also thinking about putting some speakers just before me (at the normal place of the strings of a piano), facing upward, but most speakers (and PA more so) have only a narrow diffusion angle for the high frequencies. I could of course put more and more speakers, side by side, to cover a wider angle but I don't want to put half a dozen of speakers in front of me either !!!

Re: playing live with an ochestra

Hello Luc

I would say that a set of speakers pointing your way and a set facing the rest of the musicians should be enough?
Do you have a layout of the orchestral and piano placement on stage?
That might help some?

cheers
Hans

Re: playing live with an ochestra

We didn't agree yet where the keyboard will be positioned, but I suppose it will follow, more or less, the classic rules of a piano concerto: front left.
But you gave me an idea: to use just a very small setup for me (little studio monitors, I just love my new Focal CMS50, they are amazing!), and whatever will be needed for the musicians.
In this case, I would try first with the aforementioned set of speakers behind the FOH, pointed toward the musicians, because it will be less obstrusive, visually speaking. However, this raises the problem of the delays... The sound of my own setup would arrive sooner to my ears (and the musicians behind me) than the sound of the "main monitors"...

Re: playing live with an ochestra

is the orchestra itself going to be amplified as well? i that case you could try to get a mix of that plugged in to your speakers? hmm but your piano sound would 'bleed' into that as well possibly with some delay....

a bit tricky huh?

on the other hand - wouldn't you face the same problems with a real piano?
so if you'd place all speakers near your keyboard and make that sound as close to how 'normal sound radiation' from the piano would be, you would have the same basic principle to follow as 'any' concert pianist with an orchestra right?

And for the audience the speakers would be to the left and right of the stage facing the audience like with any 'rock-concert' - you would hear those yourself less so your play would be in response to the direct sound just like the orchestra would?

Hans

Re: playing live with an ochestra

the orchestra won't be amplified at all - so shocking ! :-) - no need: the concert will be performed in an old roman church in front of maximum 350 people. And the acoustic is very nice for the orchestra. Less so for the piano: a little too reverberant, but not that much either.

With a real piano, the nice thing is that the sound, while not completely the same, is at least "all right" from all angles. So yes, I would like to have a sound source in front of me, like a piano, but "radiating" at 360°... In fact I already experienced a setup like this for a smaller performance, playing in a trio, and it was rather convincing, but awful to be seen! Imagine an array of four 10" or 12" speakers just in the middle of the orchestra?!

Hum... maybe the 2 little monitors for me and a  complement of two 8" placed not too high?

It just seems strange to me that nobody here would have faced this problem before? Since PianoTeq is aimed at replacing a real piano in all situations, I thought it was obvious...

Re: playing live with an ochestra

I was just asking about the orchestra's ampllfication, but didn't expect it depending on the size of the venue.....

Ah yes - a church - I know how the natural reverb can work against you...
a long time ago I made music for a WorldPressPhoto presentation in a big church in Amsterdam and had put a gunshot in the mix.... it 'echoed' through the whole church leaving quite an impression on all guests....

Ya I was thinking sort of a dome of speakers as well - the 360 degrees approach...
can't you think of such a solution to fit under your keyboard?...

I only play in a 'rock- environment' myself - all amplified so that's a different game all together

cheers
Hans

Re: playing live with an ochestra

Interesting problem! I have no experience playing in a church but I sing in a choir performing often in churches, so maybe I would suggest pointing three speakers close together in a semi-circle towards the audience and one speaker pointing up to the ceiling so as to give you and the orchestra some feedback while trying to get that 360 degree diffusion of a real piano.

One thing to worry about is the apparent detuning coming from far away as frequencies are absorbed and sent back sounding a bit lower. A Roman church might have a round ceiling over the musicians, keeping some of the sound unchanged and distributing it evenly to all musicians. The relative volume of this feedback can then be adjusted to the church condition.

As for the visual, I suppose you will use a keyboard on a stand with maybe a laptop partly visible somewhere, so if people are willing to accept that situation, I suppose seeing loudspeakers is not that important... just a thought

Re: playing live with an ochestra

well, as I wrote, the acoustic of the church is not a very big problem, it's reverberant, but not that much: in fact a real piano would do the job just fine! Except it's not a big church, so there would be a problem of place for the orchestra, and it's also not a big budget - to say the least...! So renting a piano was out of question.

But I would not consider sending the sound to the ceiling and waiting for it to bounce back , it's not organ I have to play it's piano! ;-)

Yes, a "dome", like the dome tweeters of monitors, but then with more power: a true piano played fortissimo goes largely above the 100 dB. That's a lot for studio monitors... Albeit? I'll try...

And for the visual, of course the laptop would be out of sight, the audience should only see a simple keyboard... Placing an array of 4 speakers just behind it and not too high seems a not-too-bad solution.

Re: playing live with an ochestra

Just use Bose L1 Model II  speakers , they have 197 degree angle sound spread, use two of them & problem will be solved ... http://www.bose.com/controller?url=/sho...ss_pkg.jsp

Re: playing live with an ochestra

Just to make a modified echo of Shumas ... in a reverberant building (like many 'cathedral-style' churches) you DON'T want to add echos off the ceiling by pointing any speakers upward ... just makes the sound muddier.

The Bose Model I or Model II would do great ... every one, audience and performers, can hear clearly.

One could try a pair of Bose Compact L1's ($1K ea, rather than $2-3K for the bigger models) and probably do well for a quiet attentive audience as a soloist, but I'd be concerned about matching a 25-piece string ensemble -- but I know they (the Compact L1) would do well as monitors -- just probably not enough "oomph" to solo against the strings.

BTW:  You'll be pleased with the PianoTeq sounds through a Bose L1 -- clean & accurate & can get plenty loud without distorting or 'coloring' the sound.

Re: playing live with an ochestra

Yes I was considering the Bose system but I was not very pleased by what I heard on a demo recently... and it's rather expensive IMO.
At the moment, I'm gonna try an old pair of JBL "Control one" + sub SB1 I still have in my living room... Old stuff but the sound is still good and with a big amp, you can reach serious levels. Have to try with the tweeters facing the ceiling. Just out of curiosity.

Re: playing live with an ochestra

And so I played... And it was all right except for my search of the "acoustic feel" of the amplification. Due to other considerations (other pieces with other soloists), I was finally placed front right of the audience, and I ended up using a pair of DB Technologies bi-amped speakers, model Opera Live 208D. Small but lot of power (200 W each, very efficient), and, believe me, you NEED that kind of power when you have to play with a saxophonist and a 25 piece string orchestra (plus a choir!). All the studio monitors I tried  where simply not able to deliver the needed level. Regarding the placement, they were placed on a stand behind me (yes, rather unconventional but effective), near a pilar of the church, pointing more or less to the audience and the orchestra respectively, with an angle of about 90° between them, I was in the middle so I heard more or less the same as everybody.
Convincing but I'm still in search of a better way to emulate the "acoustic" feeling of a piano...

Re: playing live with an ochestra

Hi Luc

Ya I can imagine you miss the direct sound that way... and just an extra speaker on top of the keyboard or something just as an extra monitor wasn't an option?
Do you have any recordings, audio or video, than you can share of the concert?
Very interesting to see and hear it...

cheers
Hans

Re: playing live with an ochestra

http://www.imageupload.org/?d=C0046EEF1

here is a picture, I have a video but the sound is very poor - as so often ! And I really had no time to verify it all by myself, I prefered concentrating on the score!

By the way, you'll see that I had to put 4 pages together in front of me, so there was not a lot of place left to put an extra monitor. But I might consider this next time: a pair of very little speakers both sides of the keyboard, yes, good idea.

Last edited by Luc Henrion (14-09-2011 13:54)

Re: playing live with an ochestra

Very interesting! I sure know a choir + an orchestra can generate a very high volume so I guess efficient speakers are needed. I see also the ceiling is rather high so my suggestion was worthless in this case. I had in mind a smaller roman church with a round dome such as this:

https://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/c...directlink

Last edited by Gilles (14-09-2011 14:56)