Topic: about midi "ghosts notes"

Hi everybody,
I worry a midi note "ghost" that fires alone ...
can someone tell me where that came from ...
is it my sound card (Alesis io2 USB) or my keyboard (Kurzweil k2500x)

thank you for your help

                                      ************
Bonjour à tous,

j'ai un souci de note midi "fantôme" qui se déclenche toute seule ...
quelqu'un saurait il me dire d'ou cela vient il ...
est ma carte son (Alesis io2 usb) ou mon clavier (Kurzweil k2500x)

merci de votre aide

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

Hello Messr. imyself,

I do understand what is meant by the term "ghost note," a midi note that seems to fire without input from the player.

The following questions need to be answered, so one may determine the origin of randomly firing midi notes:

Does this occur when you play the k2500x as a standalone unit?
Does this occur when you use the k2500x as a controller for Pianoteq?
Does this occur when you use the k2500x as a controller for other virtual instrument software?
Does this occur when you are recording multiple tracks or multiple takes into a sequencer?

* * * * *

If this problem happens fairly often, then perhaps the best way to detect them (in the midi stream) is by using a sequencer in 'record' mode to capture the spurious data along with the notes you are playing on your Kurzweil k2500x.  Assuming you can play back the recorded midi sequence, THEN you will be able to gather information about the spurious notes.

Upon reviewing the nature of the random notes in the midi stream (assuming they are present when you left the sequencer in 'record' mode, and were able to capture these spurious notes), we may obtain a better sense of the source of these extra notes.

Under normal circumstances, I would not expect the Kurzweil keyboard to be a source of spurious notes -- unless there were a loose midi cable coming out the keyboard and/or going into the computer.  (Do you have a separate midi box for handling midi, or does the sound card handle midi by means of USB cable?)   A loose or low-quality midi- or USB cable might be a source cause of spurious data:  Try switching cables, if possible, and check whether the problem persists.

About 21 years ago, when I was first getting into midi-controlled instruments, my sequencer (called Master Tracks Pro-5) was the culprit!  At times, random notes would seem to fire, and their lengths were sometimes in excess of 25 measures!  This is why I asked if this problem occurs when using the Kurzweil in standalone mode.

If you get short spikes of unwanted midi data, the sequencer data will help you determine the midi channel on which it occurred;  it may also indicate a midi continuous controller might be inadvertently switched to send midi note-on messages.


I hope some of this information may be of help to you.

Cheers,

Joe

Last edited by jcfelice88keys (20-04-2011 19:56)

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

jcfelice88keys wrote:

Hello Messr. imyself,

I do understand what is meant by the term "ghost note," a midi note that seems to fire without input from the player.

The following questions need to be answered, so one may determine the origin of randomly firing midi notes:

Does this occur when you play the k2500x as a standalone unit?
Does this occur when you use the k2500x as a controller for Pianoteq?
Does this occur when you use the k2500x as a controller for other virtual instrument software?
Does this occur when you are recording multiple tracks or multiple takes into a sequencer?

* * * * *
I hope some of this information may be of help to you.

Joe

First, thank you a lot to take time to help me...
i take a look here and there on the net, and did not find any answer...

                                        * * * * *
1)Does this occur when you play the k2500x as a standalone unit?
*Never! when i play on k2500 as standalone or in a song with k2500 sequencer and internals sounds.

2)Does this occur when you use the k2500x as a controller for Pianoteq?
*Yes! almost all the time...

3)Does this occur when you use the k2500x as a controller for other virtual instrument software?
*Yes! almost all the time...

4)Does this occur when you are recording multiple tracks or multiple takes into a sequencer?
*Yes! almost all the time...
                                        * * * * *
i use a Alésis io2 Express as external sound card and as midi box.

for the midi cable, they are all news, but for the quality, i do not know...

i enjoy that you seem saying that my k2500x is not a too bad keyboard, i ask myself if he was not a bit older ...

i have cubase essential 5 so i must try what you said to discover from where the trouble come from...

than you a lot,

hervé

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

A shot in the dark - did you perhaps try to change the MIDI cable? Sometimes it can do wonders, surprisingly enough.

Hard work and guts!

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

yesterday night, after reading jcfelice, i change place of my midi box and exchange midi cable: i play two hours without ghost note...
this morning, i have to initialize my midi configuration (but only once) and from 1 hour now, it is ok ...

i think it may be electronic "bugs" in the air because everything is very close of everything in my little home...

and yes Evildragon, you maybe right... so can you give me name of midi quality cable which maybe protect of electronic "bugs"...

thank all of you for advice
(i started to be crazy with those ghost note)

hervé

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

Another big shot in the dark - for the time being it might also be worth ensuring that the K2500SX is only transmitting on one MIDI channel, and if it has the capability to transmit polyphonic aftertouch, disable that too. The reason being that if it is transmitting a lot of MIDI data, it could overload your DAW or something else in the chain.

Greg.

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

skip wrote:

Another big shot in the dark - for the time being it might also be worth ensuring that the K2500SX is only transmitting on one MIDI channel, and if it has the capability to transmit polyphonic aftertouch, disable that too. The reason being that if it is transmitting a lot of MIDI data, it could overload your DAW or something else in the chain.

Greg.

it may be a way, i'm gone look for that too...

thank you,
hervé

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

Yep, no poly AT transmitting in K2500x, I believe.

Hard work and guts!

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

hum! then I'm going crazy with this problem of ghost notes! Not only is income, but it is with more intensity as:
1) I changed my midi cable
2) I change up my io2 Express (it is resting on my VMK)
3) I set the midi channel in Pianoteq to ensure that information passes only a single channel
4) I (I think) properly set up my MIDI keyboard

if anyone has an idea, because then I do not know what to do ...

is it possible that my alesis io2 Express is involved??

advance, thank you for your help

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

Hello imyself,

If the problem went away when you changed midi cables, and now the problem is back (even after you changed cables again), I might suggest that the problem may still lie in the quality of your midi cables.

If the midi cables you are using happened to come with the equipment you purchased, then I am sure those are the lowest quality cables possible.  Usually the lowest quality cables have injection-molded plastic connectors with cheap metal contacts.

Here is my suggestion:  Go to a store where professional grade electronic instruments are sold, an purchase one or two sets of good quality midi cables.  I forget the name of cables I use, but they are of metal rather than injection-molded plastic.  The better stores will allow you to return them for your money back (hint: use a credit card so the sale may be canceled easier).

Try these new, high-quality cables in your system for a week.  I suspect the problem will go away permanently.

Cheers,

Joe

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

jcfelice88keys:
i will buy new midi cable, hope you are right,cause it is really disturbing...
thanks

PS:i waiting Monster Cable (buy on net) and hope it will resolve my trouble

Last edited by imyself (25-04-2011 09:30)

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

Is there an arpeggiator in the kurz?
If so check if it is switched on or sending midi clock signals or alike. Maybe remote transport function or something similar. If you don't know your keyboard very well and you have no personal patch or preset I'd suggest to try a hard reset of the thing

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

etto: thank for trying helping me,
i do not use my K2500 any more, i buy 3 days ago a VMK 188 plus but the trouble is that midi "ghost note" are still there... so,i will receive Tuesday MIDI Monster cable, i buy on the net, and i really hope it is going to stop that bad midi problem...
hervé

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

After what you have explained it is clearly your midi interface somehow.
Could be a bad connection in the midi input connector since it got better exchanging the cable but then got bad again.
If a new cable doen't help it's your midi interface.

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

olepro wrote:

After what you have explained it is clearly your midi interface somehow.
Could be a bad connection in the midi input connector since it got better exchanging the cable but then got bad again.
If a new cable doen't help it's your midi interface.

i wish you are wrong... (but truth is: i am afraid you are right)
after receive my new cable i will immediately knows.

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

as i am afraid olepro may have right, can you,please, give me advice for buying a good quality usb external sound card/MIDI box...

thank you

(and,always if olepro is right; do you think it is possible/easy to fix the MIDI trouble in my alesis sound card?)

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

imyself,

An easy way to see if it's your midi cables, now that you have a VMK188plus would be to hook up a USB cable and use that for your midi input. If all is solved then it's almost definitely the midi equipment you're currently using. If not, then you're back to square one. Good luck.

Michael

Last edited by Michael H (30-04-2011 15:07)

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

Michael H wrote:

imyself,

An easy way to see if it's your midi cables, now that you have a VMK188plus would be to hook up a USB cable and use that for your midi input. If all is solved then it's almost definitely the midi equipment you're currently using. If not, then you're back to square one. Good luck.

Michael

i receive my midi monster cable today, feel happy because i can play 3 hours without any troubles and... it came back!!!

one thing i discover: one of my pedal have 2 Controller...
i assign 64 and there is 4 too ???

for Michael,

i translate your advice but i do not understand it,
my english is very poor, sorry

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

imyself,
You can use USB instead of a midi cable with the VMK188plus. Perhaps this will help you.

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

Michael H wrote:

imyself,
You can use USB instead of a midi cable with the VMK188plus. Perhaps this will help you.

ok! i do not try this yet... and this is it !!!

i take off my Alesis io2 express and every thing is fine now...
but what does it mean?
is my external sound card not good?
because, before (as a reverb) alésis was very knows for quality product and it seem that it is not same thing for external sound card right?

but in this way, i only use my little (but not too bad) altec lansing output...

do you think i may do something to fix my external soundcard ?

thank you a lot for your advice Michael, you finally found it

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

imyself,

That's good! You might also like to examine your latency settings. Perhaps you need a shorter latency setting with your Alesis io Express.

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

ok! here is what i do:
1) i exchange the usb cable
2)as i do not use any more my k2500: i do not need my old Behringer XENYX 802 (and it seem there was few little electric troubles) so i go now straight in my amplification,
3)i must admit that all my audio cables are almost new, but not the best quality (it was ok before, but not for use with midi and computer, and a external sound card)
and with latency, no problem

thank you for help

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

You're welcome!

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

EVERYTHING IS FINE NOW, YESSS!!!

i keep using my external sound card, and stop using midi cable...

what i do not understand before, it is that the VMK 188+ do not need any midi connection!

well,i buy monster cable for nothing, but i feel so good that my "ghost note" finally disappear...

Michael: merci beaucoup

Re: about midi "ghosts notes"

imyself: je vous en prie.