Topic: new VAX 77

I am basically a gigging musician and always looking for a better balance between heavy keyboard with good enough action and still portable solution.

Any experiences from this one? Is the action close to piano? How would you compare it to best digital stage pianos (for example RD700GX which I have)?

http://www.infiniteresponse.com/?n=Prod...folded.jpg

Seems to be quite innovative product. At least with this money you should get something...

Last edited by Ecaroh (01-04-2010 08:25)

Re: new VAX 77

This will surely show my age, but the thread title immediately reminds me of a VAX "mini-computer" introduced in 1977, for which I did some (assembly) programming during my university computer science studies....

http://www.yourdictionary.com/computer/vax

And no, this is not an april's fool joke...pretty nice "little" machines for the times.

Re: new VAX 77

^P
>>>

p.s This line is here because a post cannot contain only capital letters.

Re: new VAX 77

The VAX77 offers POLYPHONIC AFTERTOUCH, which is excellent news,
and it is very light and portable (magnesium alloy case, and it folds in half!)
So that makes it an excellent gigging keyboard.
I have no idea what it would be like for piano technique though.

Here's a review in Keyboard Magazine
http://www.keyboardmag.com/article/infi...010/110695

Last edited by feline1 (02-04-2010 13:56)

Re: new VAX 77

Generally, poly-AT keyboards are not the best choice for serious classical piano playing. You get a feeling like the key has no end to its pressing, which is very weird, to say the least.

Hard work and guts!

Re: new VAX 77

EvilDragon wrote:

Generally, poly-AT keyboards are not the best choice for serious classical piano playing. You get a feeling like the key has no end to its pressing, which is very weird, to say the least.

This is what I fear most: (for a piano player) does it feel strange? Does anyone have real experiences of VAX or something close to it?

Re: new VAX 77

Agree with EvilDragon, AT is weird for classical playing. It will be very hard to be happy with the another one if you have RD700GX :-)

Re: new VAX 77

No, monophonic AT is still fine. But polyphonic is a bit mess. Imagine playing a piano with clavinet keys, or something like that.

Hard work and guts!

Re: new VAX 77

yeah, although PolyAT is heaven for polysynth sounds.

I guess the only thing to do is to try one and see how it feels to you! The guy in the Keyboard Magazine review was very positive about it.

Re: new VAX 77

I have the AT turned off most of the time on my MIDIBOARD. It makes no interesting difference in the feel of the keys--the key hits a fairly hard bottom and you press harder for AT.

For pads especially, poly AT is very nice. Very very nice. I've also worked a bit with having the PAT control individual note pitch, so that I can get pedal steel note-bending effects; but it's pretty hard to control.

But for a struck note like a piano's (or Pianoteq), I'm not sure what it would control. Pitch perhaps, like a clavinet. But, if I understand correctly, Pianoteq calculates most/all parameters on 'impact' and it would be very hard to mess with them after the fact. I may be wrong...

Re: new VAX 77

feline1 wrote:

yeah, although PolyAT is heaven for polysynth sounds.

Of course! It's absolutely brimming for synth weirdness!

Hard work and guts!

Re: new VAX 77

The Vax77 does not feel like a grand piano - ref: http://www.forum-pianoteq.com/viewtopic...627#p10627

Greg.

Re: new VAX 77

doug wrote:

But for a struck note like a piano's (or Pianoteq), I'm not sure what it would control. Pitch perhaps, like a clavinet. But, if I understand correctly, Pianoteq calculates most/all parameters on 'impact' and it would be very hard to mess with them after the fact. I may be wrong...


Yeah, we're getting entirely into the realm of virtual instruments with no physical couterparts here.
I would suggest that on Pianoteq, aftertouch (poly or otherwise) would be a nice way to control the amount of resonance in sustaining notes. You could use it to make sounds like in 'Deep Blue Day' on Brian Eno's "Apollo"....

Re: new VAX 77

I took the plunge. I saw it at the website, read about it (I'm VERY techie), and I bought one. My VAX77 is the first one I've ever played or even seen up close. Now: How Is It?
1. It doesn't "feel" like a piano when you press the keys. There's no escapement jack "bump". The key-drop pressure and distance (3/8") are quite pianistic though (I got the "heavy" key-drop), and the key surface is textured like ivory instead of shiny plastic. (The whole instrument feels very expensive, dahling...) When you hook it up to Mainstage II, all of a sudden, it feels VERY much like a piano. What I really enjoyed though, was the incredible expressiveness. It's possible to play much more lyrically than with ANY other controller I've used. Without the hammer mass to throw when you play, it's possible to rip off a solo at synth speeds easily. It also doesn't fight you when you do Hammond "wipes" like a piano board does.
2. There are 77 keys, 76 of which are active for playing. The keys run from A to C, which makes it ideal for piano music - only the top octave is missing. They body of the keyboard is unusually thin at 3 1/4" at the fattest part. It folds in half, coming in at 23 1/2" long. 77 is the maximum number of keys you can fit in a board like this and still get it on a lot of airlines as carry on.
3. It has provisions for 4 analog pedals (the damper is continuous if you like). I modified a Fender Volume/Tone pedal with 10k linear pots, and it's an ideal two pedal under one foot solution. Next to that is the damper, and the fourth pedal is a pot on my wife's microphone (yeah, another mod) which I can assign to whatever she might need to adjust in Mainstage.
4. I can fit my entire kit in the back of a Mini Clubman, and wheel it to the stage without assistance or even an additional hand truck.

So, yeah, it's a little spendy. But what do you get? It can't be got anywhere else. If you want a portable rig that really works, you need to seriously consider the VAX77. I believe it's totally worth it.

Re: new VAX 77

LHogan wrote:

What I really enjoyed though, was the incredible expressiveness. It's possible to play much more lyrically than with ANY other controller I've used.

What controllers (or digipianos) have you used? I ask this because I'm curious to know what models are you comparing to your new VAX?

Re: new VAX 77

Thanks for the review!

Now, regarding the 77th key, my understanding is that there is an OPTION to have this active for playing - is that correct? (I enquired about this directly with the company some time ago)

Greg.

Re: new VAX 77

Gilles wrote:

This will surely show my age, but the thread title immediately reminds me of a VAX "mini-computer" introduced in 1977, for which I did some (assembly) programming during my university computer science studies....

http://www.yourdictionary.com/computer/vax

And no, this is not an april's fool joke...pretty nice "little" machines for the times.

Not "little" in their day.
We started the architectural development in '74 and had shipped at least a few field test machines in '76.
Unfortunately the golden goose was too good and her keepers tried to keep her laying long after she should have been a retired old grandmother goose - or somesuch analogy (-:
But for a few critical decisions... and the pest from the west - all these wretched PCs would have been micro vaxen running X_Windows (updated) OSF.
(-:

Re: new VAX 77

Another ex DECcie! Did you participate in the Notes conference called COMMUSIC, aandrmusic? I did - too much. ;^)

Greg.

Last edited by skip (23-05-2010 06:36)

Re: new VAX 77

skip wrote:

Another ex DECcie! Did you participate in the Notes conference called COMMUSIC, aandrmusic? I did - too much. ;^)

Greg.

Notes and the original Adventure game were probably the company's biggest "overhead" (-:

Re: new VAX 77

When I asked Infinite Response if there's a chance to buy VAX77 from Europe I got this answer:

"We will be receiving CE mark in 2 months. Then we will be able to sell in Europe. Shipping is free, anywhere in the world."


People in Europe, let's wait and see. Anyway this is an interesting product. At least for those of us who are tired to carry 88-keys pianos to here and there. Hopefully some day there's also chance to test it by our own hands. (I don't trust any review anymore; I just had a terrible disappointment with "celebrated" AKAI mpk 49 which I sent back...)

Re: new VAX 77

I just bought a keyboard from a pianist who plays in NYC frequently. He sold me his Fatar VMK-188 Plus because it was too heavy for him to cart around.
He told me he just bought a controller for about $3K. It turns out it was the VAX and he loves it and says it's the best keyboard action he ever played on.

Re: new VAX 77

I am the keyboard player who sold Michael H the VMK. LHogan states the VAX77 feature set and playability very eloquently. I would simply add that it is the MOST RESPONSIVE keyboard action I have ever played, being versatile enough to play organ and synth VI's with the requisite degree of flexibility and velocity. AND I can play virtual Pianos (I have Ivory, but am interested in Pianoteq 3 PRO) with an unprecedented degree of dynamic control. Plus the matte finish faux Ivory keys feel great! Worth every penny of the 3K.

Re: new VAX 77

Hey Jim! Fancy meeting you here

Re: new VAX 77

aandrmusic wrote:
skip wrote:

Another ex DECcie! Did you participate in the Notes conference called COMMUSIC, aandrmusic? I did - too much. ;^)

Greg.

Notes and the original Adventure game were probably the company's biggest "overhead" (-:


Wow! that Adventure game
I played the version ported to the Sinclair ZX Spectrum a lot.

Re: new VAX 77

DEC (or was it VAX?) "Flight" was absolutely stunning too.

I think the very first computer music software I ever ran was Csound on DEC workstation.  (bringing some semblance of on-topic-ness back ;^)

Greg.

Re: new VAX 77

Another VAX 77 user review here.

Re: new VAX 77

Here is an update of a review I posted elsewhere on this forum:

I did get a VAX77 [Aug 2010], and sold my MIDIBoard (rev 3.0) to someone in Edmonton. To put it simply, I don't miss my MIDIBoard at all- it is nice to have a smaller, lighter, modern keyboard with excellent polyphonic aftertouch. The people here will want to know about its suitability as a piano controller:

The keys are textured, and feel expensive- more like ivory than plastic. They are weighted, though lighter (I have the Heavy version) than a real piano. The action is still pretty firm, but there is no escapement bump. However when playing Pianoteq, your brain automatically adjusts to the slightly different feel, and you can play very expressively- I am very happy with the piano feel, though if it were just a bit heavier it would be perfect. The action is very fast- I can play things like the intro to Billy Joel's "Angry Young Man" without any problems. If someone were looking for a perfect piano controller, they would be better off with a dedicated 88 key instrument that tries to exactly duplicate a piano action. The VAX77 has the advantage of being smaller and lighter, and can also be used effectively for synth/organ. Another cool feature- the VAX77 has an 8va button that allows you to get to the top octave that is missing in a 76 key controller. Infinite Response (at my suggestion!) made the 8va function part of the footswitch options so that you can just touch a pedal to reach that last octave without missing a beat.

Overall I am extremely happy with it- much more manageable than the MIDIBoard, with more modern implementation and better polyphonic aftertouch. Very expressive for piano, while still being fast enough for organ/synth.

Last edited by marzzz (28-07-2011 04:07)

Re: new VAX 77

I bet a VAX88 would be a winner. For how many players is it terribly important that the keyboard can fit the size requirements for carry on luggage, as opposed to the number of players who need 88 keys? And I imagine the weight difference would be negligible.

Re: new VAX 77

Michael H wrote:

I bet a VAX88 would be a winner. For how many players is it terribly important that the keyboard can fit the size requirements for carry on luggage, as opposed to the number of players who need 88 keys? And I imagine the weight difference would be negligible.

I would have been thrilled with a non-folding 88 key version for the studio, but I asked Glenn and Van personally (at NAMM), and they have no plans of making one.

Re: new VAX 77

marzzz wrote:

I would have been thrilled with a non-folding 88 key version for the studio, but I asked Glenn and Van personally (at NAMM), and they have no plans of making one.

Perhaps there are some physical or electronic design constraints that would make an 88er unfeasible.
Too bad for whatever reason, because I suspect a lot of players won't give this controller serious consideration without 88 keys. And there's a real need for good controllers, because of all the mediocre (or worse) ones that are currently available.

Michael

Re: new VAX 77

Not to imply that the top 11 notes are never played but I suspect those strings are important for resonance and adding keys to play them seemed sensible in a non-portable instrument. Resonance isn't an issue for Pianoteq which will resonate the same whatever the number of keys on the controller. If you play those notes, 88 keys is necessary; if not it's baggage.

Re: new VAX 77

If you play together with a (double)bass-player the change is small of using the lowest notes so 77 keys would do. But on the other hand it sometimes feels good to hit a very low note very hard like thunder

Re: new VAX 77

doug wrote:

Not to imply that the top 11 notes are never played but I suspect those strings are important for resonance and adding keys to play them seemed sensible in a non-portable instrument. Resonance isn't an issue for Pianoteq which will resonate the same whatever the number of keys on the controller. If you play those notes, 88 keys is necessary; if not it's baggage.

I have a VAX77 and a special foot pedal that raises the keyboard up an octave when pressed.  With a little practice I have been able to momentarily press it for certain high notes with some ease. 

I am glad that it folds at its current size.

Re: new VAX 77

As an update, both the VAX77 and Pianoteq handle the high resolution velocity CC #88 (for 16,000+ steps of velocity instead of the standard 0-127), and with a Korg DS-1H pedal, the half-pedaling techniques work well with the VAX77/Pianoteq.

Re: new VAX 77

marzzz wrote:

As an update, both the VAX77 and Pianoteq handle the high resolution velocity CC #88 (for 16,000+ steps of velocity instead of the standard 0-127), and with a Korg DS-1H pedal, the half-pedaling techniques work well with the VAX77/Pianoteq.

I wonder if any of you lucky VAX owners would please upload a midi file demonstrating all of this velocity goodness? I would like to see just how much information is generated.

Actually, a snapshot from your DAW showing the CC lanes would be alright too...

Thanks!

[edit]
I don't think this is currently possible with any DAW...never mind.

Last edited by johnrule (31-07-2011 23:19)