Topic: Off Topic: H1n1

Okay, you will call me the "king of Off-Topic", but as this is a international virtual communitty, people from everywhere, I want to ask:

Did you took the H1N1 vacine, or refused it ?

There was a lot of people, even many doctor and nurses, who refused to take the vacin as they did not trust. Suspects of possible neurological damage.

Also the manufacurer have a contract that ensure he is not legally responsible for any problem that happen to people who took the vacin.

Some scientists said that vacines with high amounts of mercury had increased incidence of autism a lot:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YNA7nt3XUzY&NR=1

Last edited by Beto-Music (19-04-2010 03:46)

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

I took it.

I think there is too much "expert advice" floating around out there.

Glenn

__________________________
Procrastination Week has been postponed.  Again.

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

I work in a hospital pharmacy, so I have strong feelings about this subject.  I'm wary of products that our wonderful pharmaceutical companies (can you smell the sarcasm?) rush into production -- they don't see the forest for the money they can make from the trees, so to speak.  The US was in panic mode when the outbreaks occurred last year (typical idiocy), so the hype to get the vaccine was very high.  Not being one to follow such hype, I dragged my butt about getting vaccinated, though -- as a hospital employee -- we were more or less compelled to get both the "regular seasonal" flu and H1N1 vaccines (I opted to take the nasal form for both).

(And, to be honest, I think that I had the "piggy" virus back in October -- I was out of work for 2 weeks with all sorts of lovely symptoms which eventually abated.  Upside:  I had plenty of time to play with Pianoteq, even if I did feel like the living dead at the time!  I never had any official tests done [better to stay away from people -- doctors' offices don't need you to bring the enemy to their door ;^], but the consensus at Employee Health was H1N1, not seasonal flu.  Ironically, I still had to get both vaccines, and the H1N1 wasn't available to us for about another month afterward -- so it wouldn't have done me a darn bit of good to try to get it earlier, anyway!!!)

The whole scenario played out in a fairly sloppy fashion here, thankfully with no pandemic flare-ups.  (You would've thought that the plague was in town, with the way the media constantly harped on the subject.)

Would I have refused to take the vaccine if it hadn't been virtually required by my job?  Probably, or I would have just been too lazy to get it anyway.  "First times" with drug companies tend to be the scariest;  one just loves hearing about this-or-that fault being found with a med after it's been released and consumed.

As for mercury poisoning and/or autism -- who knows?  So many variables come into play that you almost have a hard time singling out a vaccine as the root cause of such ills.  Damned if you do, damned if you don't...

"Our developers, who art in Toulouse, hallowed be thy physical-models.
Thy version 4 come, thy new instruments be done, in the computer as it is in the wood!"

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

In a TV reportage they said that France bought vacines for their entire population, but latter found that 83% of people did not want to took, including many doctors.

So 83% of a lot of millions euros was wasted.
This money could had be used to finance research for the creation of perfect modelled pianos by pianoteq.
Háaa háaaa...
Sorry the joke, Philippe.    ;-)

H1N1 sounds like the name of a nice pianoteq model anyway.


Honestly, I think medicine it's a quite stopped in time. It's one of the things that less progress in last years.  They try to hide this fact, by pumping informatic technology into it, but very few real medicine accomplishment was made. They still use basically therapies from 20 years ago or more.
Can you imagine using a 25 years old computer today ? Or a 20 years digital piano ?

Almostv everyhing they promess did not come or in practice proved to be a scam or near that.

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

To be honest, my situation is way different from that of most people; I have CLL so a virus like H1N1 is too big a risk for me to take, and my age is WAY past the point of autism being a problem (even if it is caused by an element in vaccines).  Besides I've been getting flu shots for going on twenty years and I'm still here.

G

__________________________
Procrastination Week has been postponed.  Again.

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

Wow! this is off topic. I didn't take it. I'd have forgotten about it now. When I saw the heading of this post I thought this might be a new piano, sorry.

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

Beto-Music wrote:

Some scientists said that vacines with high amounts of mercury had increased incidence of autism a lot:

Strange topic to be reading on the Pianoteq forum!

I live in the UK and am not in a 'high risk group' (very old, very young, or a front-line health care worker), so I didn't get the vaccine. I didn't get swine flu either
My other half is a nurse and so he got it, and experienced no ill effects apart from a stiff arm for a couple of afternoons...

As a chemist, I'll have to pick you up on the whole "mercury" thing.

They don't put mercury metal in vaccines - that would be unsane, as mercury metal is well known for making people mad as a hatter. Saying that there is "mercury" in vaccines makes people think of environmental disasters like the Minamata tragedy in Japan
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minamata_disease

In actual fact, an organo-mercury compound called thiomersal was used in some vaccines as a preservative (to stop them going mouldy, basically). Concerns were raised about this but the scientific consensus has repeatedly been that they could find no toxicity problems with it at all (nonetheless, to please people, they still decided to phase it out)
You can read a fair summary of it here
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thiomersal_controversy

Regarding the "rise" of autism:
autism is a "spectrum" of behaviours and personalities which society has decided are "abnormal". It is not a "disease" with a diagnosable physical cause.
If you take a historical perspective, you will see that over the centuries, "society" has had many fashions for varies types of "madness" that it decides it does not like.  A century ago, women were regularly getting diagnosed with "hysteria", a few centuries before that, they were getting diagnosed as "witches"... 
...there have always been people who are "autistic", and whom "normal" people have declared as "abnormal" in some way (Dalton, Dirac, Gary Numan...   ...  without a great many of them   a lot of these bloody "norms" would still be living in caves.

My advice would be:
- don't use silly YouTube videos with scary music as a reliable source of information.
- be highly skeptical when "society" tells you that increasing amounts of people are mentally "abnormal"

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

Beto-Music wrote:

Honestly, I think medicine it's a quite stopped in time. It's one of the things that less progress in last years.  They try to hide this fact, by pumping informatic technology into it, but very few real medicine accomplishment was made. They still use basically therapies from 20 years ago or more.
Can you imagine using a 25 years old computer today ? Or a 20 years digital piano ?

Almostv everyhing they promess did not come or in practice proved to be a scam or near that.


With all due respect, I think this is a daft thing to say.
There are dozens of peer-reviewed medical research journals in the world, publishing new medical research every month!
New procedures, new therapies, new drugs are developed all the time.
A couple of years ago I worked for a medical equipement manufacturer (radiotherapy equipment), they were continually developing improved machines that could do better imaging, more accurate beaming, dosage...
And if you go into a hospital today, you will not find them using a 25 year old computer.
And more to the point, human bodies have not changed for several hundred thousand years....

Really, what you typed just sounds ignorant to me, and the sort of handwaving rubbish that one tends to read on quack websites (who usually have some 'natural' wonderpill to sell you for $99.99)

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

Feline1

I'm usually skeptical. Don't use to believe in conspiracy theories. But I searched a lot, and heard onpions of scientists on TV, not just youtubers video creator".
Also, most french doctors did not trusted the vacin, and you have to remamber that French medicine it's  really very good and care a lot about people, much more than for example USA medical system. I don't think they are ignorant !

I'm not saying the vacine will kill bilions to reduce human population, like some sick lunatic youtube videos stated. I just spot that maybe it's not safe enough to justify a large scale imunization against a type of flu that do not kill enough.

I'm just rising a discussion. Some researches really noticed a very high increase in authism after the 80's.  Change in diagnostic aproachs is the reason  ???   I don't know...   Maybe yes, maybe not.

I agre and sympathize with your commentary about "normal" people always classifying "abnormal " people.  I'm sure many "abnormals" can be great person, more sane than ordinary people.  While many idiots, from a given "usual brand fashion actual generation", are see as normal.
If a kid is too playful he is hiperactive. If he do not play enough he is slight authist.  A century ago if you was not a racist or had no religion you would be see as a sick or crazy.
But hey, If I had told about the possibility of over prescription of drugs to active kids, you would say I was silly conspiracy believer.  And there is a record increase in drugs prescription for kids. From drugs for hiperactive to anti depressing drugs.


About medicine, I also see a lot of news everywhere, suposed great discoveries, a lot of research and new drugs.  But in practice I see the doctors doing the same old things, same therapies, with minor modifications, but general the same things a decade or two ago, and people still always compalin.  The new discoveries looks like SCI_Fi and do not get much in practice, or took 3 times more time than the estimated to became available.
  So I take the practical facts to say that medicine sesms stop.

   Diagnoses with 3D ressoance seems great. But only tell where a person is  &*%¨#$@(#/]=   .  It did not solve someone's problem.

Last edited by Beto-Music (19-04-2010 22:22)

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

Hey... I like my Amiga 4000 and my Atari Mega ST.  Don't knock it...
(actually I'd be glad to sell my Amiga Toaster systems but they can bury my Atari with me)

"Downing a fifth results in diminished capacity."

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

I caught h1n1 before the vaccine was available so I didn't need to get the shot

it's very hard to tell if the vaccine helped prevent something serious or if it was all money wasted; sometimes it's hard to tell victory from defeat

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

On Brazil there was a large vaccinations to prevent yellow fever (transmited by a mosquito), but they stopped  that several years ago cause the cases of complications, deccurent vacin application, was too high compared to the very few fatalities of the yellow fever.

The money that was used in vacins is now invested on campaign to fight the mosquito. I mean, 50% of the money, cause the rest is probably stolen due corruption.

doug wrote:

I caught h1n1 before the vaccine was available so I didn't need to get the shot

it's very hard to tell if the vaccine helped prevent something serious or if it was all money wasted; sometimes it's hard to tell victory from defeat

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

I think most people agree that the swine flu was "hyped" in the media, governments felt obliged to "respond" and provide access to a vaccine, and it's certainly something to be wary of - any new drug will have side effect risks, and these may outweigh the risk of the disease.

Bear in mind, though, that at least with a vaccine, you only get it once, rather than having to take a course of it which may take weeks or months...

When I see middle-class parents on television complaining that their children aren't normal enough, I do get very skeptical.
DIAGNOSIS of children as autistic has certainly increased, yes.
Diagnosis and concern about other things has decreased - for example, for many decades in the western world, from victorian times until the 1950s, there was great medical concern about child masturbating. We can all snigger about it now, but this was considered a serious social and medical problem which was damaging children and society.
You will not find many medics concerned about this now, diagnosing an excess of it, or proscribing ways to reduce it. But I very much doubt children are doing less of it.

A historical analysis of these types of things can provide great insight to societies' neuroses and how they are expressed regarding what is "abnormal". Michael Foucault wrote a lot about such things, for example "The Birth of the Clinic" and "Madness and Civilization" being classic texts...

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

Interesthin, Feline 1

Here some more facts.

Up to early 10's of 20th century women was really hysterical creatures to medicine. If they wanted to work and have own life, could got a bad diagnosis.
The treatment to hysteria was vaginal massages, and most visits of women to doctors, about 60%, was to get this "treatment".

There was several anti-psychiatric movements in the 60's and 70's, If I remamber well a documentary.  They did a test to catch the Drs. A guy went to a pychiatric hospital and said that heard the world "tud" (or something like) all the time. He was diagnosed with a lot of bad things, they give drugs to hin.
After he go to press and tell everything, this was a huge bomb. The Drs said that was just a isoleted mistake and that didn't use to happen. So the guy said that some times would send his people, without tell nothing, to the hospital, and would see if the Drs was able to identify which was those fakes among all people who went to the hospital.

After some time the Dr said that identify a given number, some dozens of fakes, and the guy of the test went again and said that sent nobody.


What about coffe ??? 
Every years there is a article saying "Don't drink cofee". The next years another article come and said, Ok drink cofee".   It's like some hairstyle fashion.
Or like medical articles diets:  "Do not eat fat, eat carbohydrates. " But some time latter:  "Eat fats and red meat, do not eat carbohydrates."

Superman comic was a evilt influence. At least was what said a famous psychiatric about 80 years ago. It would corrupt teen's mind and lead to criminality. 
Superman a bad guy ???  I can't understand how !
He also said Wonder Woman would turn girls lesbians.


Maybe some kids are not such sick needing lot's of medication, but just variants of nature, which own speciall hability. Glenn Gould was a briliant pianist, and had Asperger syndrome. 
What would be if Dr had treated hin with lots of drugs ?

Last edited by Beto-Music (20-04-2010 18:42)

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

I have "aspergers syndrome" myself.

It is quite handy for beta-testing the minutiae of software lol

Conversely I often dispair at what I consider to be the irrational, slap-dash, non-systematic behaviour of many of the "normal" musicians I work with

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

I supose you read music sheet very well, quite easily.

Just for fun now:

Do you see a apple, a cicular red figure, or Steve Jobs ?



PunBB bbcode test


:-)

Take as a friendly joke.

feline1 wrote:

I have "aspergers syndrome" myself.

It is quite handy for beta-testing the minutiae of software lol

Conversely I often dispair at what I consider to be the irrational, slap-dash, non-systematic behaviour of many of the "normal" musicians I work with

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

ahine!

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

I didn't want to offend.

Even to ordinary people there are figures tests to say what is the first thing that come in mind.

Most people would just say a apple. Pablo Picasso could say other thing.

Re: Off Topic: H1n1

I'm not offended