Topic: Can you create a "felt" piano using Standard or Pro?

I own Stage v6 and previously was asking about "voicing" in standard & pro. While I did get a couple of responses I wasn't able, for various reasons, to deduce the answer from them.

Here's a more specific question that I think gets at the heart of what I am trying to find out:

Native Instruments have just released their "Noire" piano (https://www.native-instruments.com/en/p...eys/noire/) which includes both a "pure" and a "felt" version. From the walktrhough video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALzLIDyRk_8&t=533s) you can see them putting felt pads up against the strings.

With either Standard or Pro editions would it be possible to simulate this action of adding felt to create a softer piano sound?

Thanks.

Matt

As an aside I love what they have done with the "particle engine" in that instrument to create a rhymically associated accompaniment to a solo piano. I only wish they'd made it a separate instrument so I could use it with Pianoteq!

Last edited by mowerm (26-03-2019 15:42)

Re: Can you create a "felt" piano using Standard or Pro?

mowerm wrote:

With either Standard or Pro editions would it be possible to simulate this action of adding felt to create a softer piano sound?

This is exactly what the moderator (or "celeste") pedal does, so I presume it's available in all versions of Pianoteq...

PS According to E. Good in his Giraffes, Black Dragons, and Other Pianos: A Technological History From Cristofori to the Modern Concert Grand (1982), the moderator felt (or leather) was "graduated in thickness across its short dimension.  The farther down one pushed the pedal, the farther the rail lowered and the thicker the material through which the hammer struck the strings. With the thicker material, the sound was softer and more muffled." (p.22).  Now, on my own 1790s Koenicke as well as the many other early pianos with moderators that I've encountered over the years I've never seen this sort of behavior (rather, as we have in Pianoteq, it's either on or off), but it still sounds like a cool feature to play with... @devs: 'possible to include this sort of linear scaling of the celeste pedal in future versions?

Last edited by _DJ_ (26-03-2019 16:12)
Matthieu 7:6

Re: Can you create a "felt" piano using Standard or Pro?

Take note Modartt, no piano lid!

Seriously, I suggest you download a standard Pianoteq demo and try it out for yourself. 

Although you get added per note parameter controls in Pianoteq PRO over Pianoteq Standard, you have a pretty good idea anyway of the enormous Pianoteq possibilities with just the standard demo.

Personally, I often play with the parameters such as Direct sound duration, Hammer hardness, Spectrum profile, Hammer noise, Strike point, Sympathetic resonance, Duplex scale, Damper position and duration both, those parameters of the soundboard, and even Mute, as all of these on the standard interface, can quickly lead to your sought outcome.

Additionally, the free demos of Oeksound software (Spiff and Soothe) its transient control and resonance suppressor, might help you for a thirty (30) day period minimum, if you ever find the Pianoteq demo somehow insufficient by itself to reproduce the result.

You get Oeksound software at, https://oeksound.com.

Last edited by Amen Ptah Ra (31-03-2019 17:19)
Pianoteq 8 Studio Bundle, Pearl malletSTATION EM1, Roland (DRUM SOUND MODULE TD-30, HandSonic 10, AX-1), Akai EWI USB, Yamaha DIGITAL PIANO P-95, M-Audio STUDIOPHILE BX5, Focusrite Saffire PRO 24 DSP.

Re: Can you create a "felt" piano using Standard or Pro?

Hi mowerm,


For Pianoteq Stage, here's a nice routine in 3 steps...


in Pianoteq Stage:


1
Good old Mallet Bounce settings (experiment with 'sync' for rhythmic possibilities - and humanize slider etc. This tool is delightfully set up in the Pianoteq instrument "Cimbalom" BTW - real world reference in other words) BTW this predates the particle engine by years I believe. I'd strongly suggest it could be inspired by it.


2
For 'felt' try setting 'dynamics' all the way right (play soft to get very soft tones, that way your occasional hard strikes can stand out more brilliantly - dynamics is quite a simple but evocative step).


3
For getting deeper 'filmic' overall sound, try long plate reverb (it's a preset in Pianoteq's) and mix it quite high and work it down to suit.



Those things alone are not going to make an exact match - but you can create interestingly "similar" effects just with existing tools available in Stage.



Getting somewhat closer is possible with Pianoteq Standard and Pro, not to mention, esp. with a DAW with a suitable range of production effects.



Definitely _DJ_' suggestion of the celest pedal is spot on (as too are items mentioned by Amen) for softer sound. Why not set up the 4 software pedals (right click them and choose - it's that simple) like 1 celest, 2 harmonic, 3 Mozart rail, 4 sustain. In Pianoteq's interface, left-click the pedals you want to stay down.. then play and tweak. If you have physical pedals with 2 or more pedals, even better control.

There's no single way, nor one correct way to achieve a particular sound - but the above concepts seem to be on a good track (time spent breaking the tools in Pianoteq Standard and Pro (or Studio with all pianos in one go) is simply the best way to learn to fish, so to speak). I make a lot of filmic presets and use all the above often. Although I make my own sounds, I would tend to steer away from highly recognisable famous artist's piano sounds (that's just in my work-flow, but for others it would be a winner to sound like other famous artists).

Pianoteq Studio Bundle (Pro plus all instruments)  - Kawai MP11 digital piano - Yamaha HS8 monitors

Re: Can you create a "felt" piano using Standard or Pro?

+1

please add different modelled felts to pianoteq

Many Thanks

Re: Can you create a "felt" piano using Standard or Pro?

Having worked with a number of Yamaha Upright pianos in my piano tuning career, I have toyed with the felt damper system in these types of pianos.  The result is a highly muffled sound with comparatively little dynamic range, and relatively quiet sound, even while attempting to play loudly:

1) Set all of the hammer hardnesses to their minimum values;

2)  Reduce the Dynamic Range slider to approximately 15dB or less;

3) Adjust overall volume level to taste.



Cheers,

Joe

Re: Can you create a "felt" piano using Standard or Pro?

I find that setting all hammer hardnesses to 0 makes the sound too bell-like in a bad way, not how it actually sounds in felt presets of Una Corda or Noire. There needs to be SOME hardness to them, still, so I suggest putting all hammer hardnesses to something between 0.10 and 0.20, and then increasing various noises, dropping dynamics to some 20 dB rather than 15 dB but limiting the velocity curve to something like Velocity = [0, 127; 0, 96], and using the Vintage or Tube timbral EQ preset.

Playing with mic positions should also help in gaining interesting perspectives in the sound.

Last edited by EvilDragon (28-03-2019 08:11)
Hard work and guts!

Re: Can you create a "felt" piano using Standard or Pro?

Just made an FXP due to these kinds of recent threads and particularly for the OP's mention of the 'particle engine' - FilmEsque for C. Bechstein DG. It's based on various preset tweaks I made in the past and hoping it might show that Pianoteq can certainly be used like the Noir.

If OP or others have different pianos (other than the Bechstein) I could port it for them and upload those too - just let me know here.

I've been hoping to get around to uploading FXPs for a long time - so probably a good time to start.

Interested to know if OP and others hear something they like about it - and would certainly take input about new versions for pianos other than the C. Bechstein DG (if OP ) or making additional 'felt + particle engine-like' changes desired.

It should work for Stage as well as Standard and Pro, since using mainly the existing tools available in Stage. It would be possible to go in any direction from this point I feel.

Although, that FXP addresses more about the particle engine at this stage by providing a humanzied rhythmic rolling echo (different tones), if you disable the 'wah' effect, the piano does have some reasonably similar tones to the Noir.

Just pedaling the celeste and sustain or una-corda pedal really controls tonal shifts.

I figure with more tweaking than I've done towards the felt related aspects, it's likely to be able to get closer to the effects of the felt piano too.

Pianoteq Studio Bundle (Pro plus all instruments)  - Kawai MP11 digital piano - Yamaha HS8 monitors

Re: Can you create a "felt" piano using Standard or Pro?

Qexl, to quote Dave Bowman from 2001 A Space Odyssey, "MY God!  It's full of stars!"

Absolutely brilliant!  Your use of Mallet Bounce works beautifully to create particles, shaped by the delays and Wah Wahs.  They appear to vary with velocity and speed/number of notes struck.  Very creative, you are.

- David

Re: Can you create a "felt" piano using Standard or Pro?

Thank you so much David! Glad it's being enjoyed All my best to you.

Pianoteq Studio Bundle (Pro plus all instruments)  - Kawai MP11 digital piano - Yamaha HS8 monitors