Topic: ERARD vs CD and BLÜTHNER vs CD

Some days ago I attended a soirée with a very old Erard, restored by Frits Janmaat, Amsterdam. I enjoyed it very much. Also bought A CD with recordings of Liszt, played on an Erard, 2.60 m, dated 1889.

Some time ago I purchased a CD with also music of Liszt, but played on a Blüthner. So now I have the full collection for making comparisons between the PianoTeq models and the CD recordings.

I downloaded the MIDI files from Internet and without any editing submitted them to the standalone PT version. Any mistakes aren't mine. Of course there is a huge difference between a living pianist and a midi file, also I couldn't get the same reverbs. I hope I caught the right timbre and sound of the real pianos in the fxp presets.

ERARD

Ballade 1 F. Chopin, on PT:  https://www.box.com/s/w5rkxxfnkwof1ygl3khc
Polonaise nr. 2, F. Liszt,  on PT: https://www.box.com/s/ybno8cftge1tl5ddo4vf

Polonaise nr. 2, F. Liszt, from CD: https://www.box.com/s/pg96s6wmuob215e8cv3o
The preset (fxp): https://www.box.com/s/n8t5vxydzh4zpq84zp2n

BLÜTHNER

Hungarian Rhapsody nr. 12 on PT: https://www.box.com/s/p2qkp2ufm8xsjkill2w9
Hungarian Rhapsody nr. 2 on PT: https://www.box.com/s/nnt0zgj150x1rf4jqc37
The preset based upon Studio Recording AB : https://www.box.com/s/2gnbecignp40ncep56r1

Hungarian Rhapsody nr. 12 from CD: https://www.box.com/s/saogpbnpaubsnr7ka7rm
Hungarian Rhapsody nr. 2 from CD: https://www.box.com/s/ww5offwnsvmlitq85cij

The Erard recordings on CD, played by Alexei Orlowetsky
The Blüthner recordings on CD, played by Artur Pizarro

Due to the copyright issues those CD files have respiration date until next may,21

Hopefully this contributed something to your fxp library/settings.

With regards,

Raymond

Website (only in dutch for now) http://www.demuziekvanraymondrobijns.nl

Re: ERARD vs CD and BLÜTHNER vs CD

The Hungarian Rhapsody it's played too fast on pianoteq compared to the CD.

Re: ERARD vs CD and BLÜTHNER vs CD

Beto-Music wrote:

The Hungarian Rhapsody it's played too fast on pianoteq compared to the CD.

True, but did you see this line in my original message: " I downloaded the MIDI files from Internet and without any editing submitted them to the standalone PT version "

Raymond

Website (only in dutch for now) http://www.demuziekvanraymondrobijns.nl

Re: ERARD vs CD and BLÜTHNER vs CD

My piano is an Erard baby grand, but overstrung with Schwander action from 1900 something. I love it. If I would know how to, or have good mics, I would record from it.